Rotten Egg Smell in Water: Hydrogen Sulfide and Sulfate
A rotten-egg smell is hydrogen sulfide gas. Which taps smell, and when, tells you the cause.
| Cause | How to tell | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| The water heater | Only the hot water smells. | This is not a filter problem. Ask a water heater dealer about swapping the magnesium anode rod for one made of another metal, such as aluminum, and have a plumber do the work. |
| The water softener | Hot and cold both smell, but only the softened water. | You do not need a new filter. Disinfect the softener the way its maker or installer tells you. |
| Sulfur bacteria in the well or pipes | Strong when you first turn on the tap, then gone after it runs, or it comes and goes. | This is not a filter problem. Shock chlorinate the well and plumbing. The smell often comes back. |
| Hydrogen sulfide in the groundwater | Every tap, hot and cold, all the time. | Treatment sized to the amount: activated carbon at low levels, then aeration, an oxidizing filter such as manganese greensand, or a chlorine feed and filter as the level rises. Have it measured first. |
| Sulfate | A lab test shows it. | Reverse osmosis certified to NSF/ANSI 58 that names sulfate on the label. |
| Sewage, rarely | Rare. A lab test tells you. | Do not buy a filter yet. Test for coliform bacteria and nitrate first. |
To be sure before you spend, test first. Find the free or low-cost public test in your state, then enter your numbers on our results page to see what each one means and what fixes it.
The sniff test
You can sort out the cause at your own taps today, for free, before you pay for a lab test or a filter. The Vermont Department of Health says: "Smell the water coming out of the hot and cold water faucets to find out which faucets have the "rotten egg" smell. It will often be more noticeable from the hot water because more of the gas is vaporized. Your sense of smell becomes dull quickly, so the best time to check is after you have been away from your home for a few hours."1 Each section below starts with what that test found. One more clue: "Hydrogen sulfide gas can cause black stains on silverware and plumbing fixtures."1
Hot water only
"If the smell is only from the hot water faucet, the problem is likely to be in the water heater." "An anode is a metal rod, usually made of magnesium metal, that is installed to reduce corrosion of the water heater tank."1
The fix. Vermont says: "A replacement anode may provide corrosion protection without contributing to the production of hydrogen sulfide gas. Contact a water heater dealer to find out if a replacement anode made of a different material, such as aluminum, can be installed."1 Taking the rod out without a replacement has a cost. Penn State Extension says: "Removal could cause increased corrosion and reduced life of the hot water heater and will likely void the manufacturer's warranty."2 And from Vermont: "Unless you are very familiar with the operation and maintenance of the water heater, you should contact a plumber to do the work."1
Softened water only
"If the smell is in both the hot and cold faucets, but only from the water treated by a water softener (and not in the untreated water), the problem is likely to be sulfur bacteria in the water softener."1
The fix. Vermont says to "contact the manufacturer or the installer to find out how to disinfect the treatment devices."1
Strong at first, then gone
"If the smell is strong when the water in both the hot and cold faucets is first turned on, and it goes away after the water has run for a while, or if the smell comes and goes, the problem is likely to be sulfur bacteria in the well or plumbing."1 Penn State Extension says of those bacteria: "These bacteria feed on small amounts of sulfur in the water and thrive in the low-oxygen environments present in groundwater wells and plumbing systems." "Although sulfur-reducing bacteria can impart taste and odor in the water, they do not cause human health concerns."2
The fix. Vermont says: "Disinfect the well and plumbing by flushing with a strong chlorine solution, which is called shock chlorination."1 A licensed well contractor can do it. Chlorine leaves its own smell in a well for a while, and our bleach smell guide covers that. Penn State Extension says: "In most cases, sulfur-reducing bacteria and hydrogen sulfide odor will return quickly after shock chlorination."2 And: "Frequent shock chlorination can be damaging to private water systems; so, if shock chlorination is required more frequently than every six months to keep slime-forming bacteria in check, other control options should be explored."3
Every tap, all the time
"If the smell is strong when the water in both the hot and cold faucets is first turned on, and is more or less constant and does not go away, the problem is likely to be hydrogen sulfide in the groundwater."1 Vermont adds a safety note: "Sulfur bacteria are not harmful, but hydrogen sulfide gas in the air can be hazardous at high levels. It is important to take steps to remove the gas from the water, or vent the gas to the outside so that it does not collect in low-lying spaces".1
The check. The gas escapes from an ordinary bottle. Connecticut's health department says: "The water sample must be chemically stabilized immediately after collection, since hydrogen sulfide is a gas that can easily escape from the sample."4 Vermont says: "If you determine that the problem is the groundwater, you can have a water treatment specialist come out and measure the concentration of the gas directly from your faucet."1 2 public tests we list check for hydrogen sulfide or sulfide, and 1 of them is free. The public test link at the top of this page shows which ones serve you and what each costs.
The fix, by the number.
- Under about 1 mg/L. Penn State Extension says: "When the water contains a small hydrogen sulfide concentration, less than about 1.0 mg/L, activated carbon filtration may be effective."2
- Up to about 2 mg/L. Aeration, which bubbles the gas out, is an option. Penn State Extension says: "Aeration is not usually efficient enough to remove all offensive odor at high hydrogen sulfide concentrations; thus, it is normally not used when hydrogen sulfide concentrations exceed about 2 mg/ L."2
- Up to about 6 mg/L. An oxidizing filter, such as manganese greensand. Vermont says: "This is effective for hydrogen sulfide levels up to about 6 mg/L."1
- Over 6 mg/L. A chemical feed, often chlorine, then a filter. Vermont says of that oxidation and filtration setup: "This is effective for hydrogen sulfide levels up to and exceeding 6 mg/L."1
Sulfate
Connecticut's health department says: "Sulfates are part of naturally occurring minerals contained within soil and rock formations." "Elevated sulfate levels in water may have a laxative effect that can lead to dehydration and is mostly a concern for infants."4 EPA's secondary standard for sulfate is 250 mg/L, a guideline for taste that EPA does not enforce (EPA).
The check. 35 public tests we list check for sulfate, and 1 of them is free. The same search finds them. Connecticut's health department says: "It is important to have your water tested by a certified laboratory to determine the concentration before purchasing any treatment system."4
The fix. This is what the results tool shows for a high sulfate number:
- Under-sink reverse osmosis. Reverse osmosis may reduce sulfate. Look for NSF/ANSI 58 certification that names sulfate on the label. (CDC)
Sewage, rarely
Vermont says: "In most cases, the rotten egg smell does not mean your water quality is bad. However, the gas may be present as a result of sewage or other pollution in rare cases. That's why it's best to also test your well for total coliform bacteria and nitrate."1
Sources
- Vermont Department of Health, Hydrogen Sulfide in Drinking Water
- Penn State Extension, Hydrogen Sulfide (Rotten Egg Odor) in Water Wells
- Penn State Extension, Iron and Sulfur Bacteria: a Slimy Problem
- Connecticut Department of Public Health, Hydrogen sulfide and sulfate in private drinking water wells
Checked November 15, 2026.
